Killing dogs for meat illegal, rules South Korean court

SEOUL – Agence France-Presse

A South Korean court has ruled the killing of dogs for meat is illegal, in a landmark decision that animal rights activists said on June 21 could pave the way to outlawing eating canines.

The meat has long been a part of South Korean cuisine, with about 1 million dogs believed to be eaten annually.

But consumption has declined as South Koreans increasingly embrace the idea of dogs as man’s best friend rather than livestock, with the practice now something of a taboo among younger generations and pressure from activists mounting.

Even so it remains a legal grey area. Despite no specific ban, authorities have invoked hygiene regulations or animal protection laws that ban cruel slaughter methods to crack down on dog farms and restaurants ahead of international events such as the Pyeongchang Olympics.

Animal rights group Care last year filed complaints against a dog farm operator in Bucheon, accusing him of “killing animals without proper reasons” and violating building and hygiene regulations, and prosecutors later charged him.

He was convicted by the Bucheon City court, which ruled that meat consumption was not a legal reason to kill dogs, and fined 3 million won ($2,700). He waived his right to appeal.

Care lawyer Kim Kyung-eun welcomed the ruling -- made in April but with details only released this week -- telling AFP: “It is very significant in that it is the first court decision that killing dogs for dog meat is illegal itself.”

The precedent “paved the way for outlawing dog meat consumption entirely”, she added.

Care leader Park So-youn said her group was tracking down dog farms and slaughter houses across the country with a view to filing similar complaints against them to judicial authorities.

“Over the past decades, public discourse over dog meat consumption has shifted towards banning it,” she said. “The dog meat industry will take greater heat because of the court ruling.”

A lawmaker from the ruling Democratic Party introduced a bill in parliament this week that would effectively ban killing dogs for meat.

The measure would limit the slaughter of animals for food to species classed as livestock, which does not include canines.

But some South Koreans object to what they describe as cultural double standards.

Dog is usually eaten in the country as a summertime delicacy, with the greasy red meat -- invariably boiled for tenderness -- believed to increase energy.

A survey last year found that 70 percent of South Koreans do not eat dogs, but only about 40 percent believe the practice should be banned.

Similar debates have emerged in other Asian nations where dogs are eaten.

China’s most notorious dog meat festival in the southwestern town of Yulin has continued to draw crowds despite international outrage.

The Bucheon court decision sparked angry protests from dog farmers, whose premises usually double as slaughter houses as the government does not license abattoirs to kill dogs.

“This is outrageous. We can’t accept the ruling that killing of dogs for dog meat consumption amounts to killing animals on a whim,” Cho Hwan-ro, a representative from an association of dog farms, said on YTN television.

There are some 17,000 dog farms across the country, Cho said, calling for the government to explicitly legalize dog meat consumption and license dog slaughter houses. “Otherwise, we’ll fight to the end,” he added.

“Dogs for eating and dogs as pets must be separated,” he said, adding they were different breeds, fed differently and raised for different purposes.

“Cows, pigs, chickens and ducks are all raised to be consumed and why not dogs?” he said.